This division might be the messiest one in all of football. The Colts could be very tough if Carson Wentz is healthy and playing at his best, those are two very big ifs. The Texans are a dumpster fire but they could have the division’s best offense if Deshaun Watson had any chance of playing, there’s almost zero chance of that happening. The Jaguars have hope, his name is Trevor Lawrence, but they might get that hope killed behind a suspect offensive line. Oh, and no one knows if Urban Meyer can coach NFL football. The Titans are probably the one consistent thing in the division but they are replacing Arthur Smith at offensive coordinator with Todd Downing, that’s a downgrade. They are hoping Julio Jones has something left in the tank and for a team that has used it’s TEs quite well over the last several years, they have very little there right now. The Titans’ defense has struggled lately and I don’t think counting on Bud Dupree to fix everything is a recipe for success. The only way I’ll be surprised with the winner of this division is if the Texans pull it off with Tyrod Taylor leading the way and defense with more holes than a screen door.
Tennessee Titans
When in doubt go with the team with the sure thing at QB and a RB that runs like a freight train. Ryan Tannehill is never going to be mistaken for Peyton Manning or Tom Brady but he knows who he is and plays within himself. Arthur Smith did a masterful job the past several years helping Tannehill be his best self, it’s up to Todd Downing now. Downing doesn’t have a long track record calling plays and what he does have is less than stellar. However, it’s a lot easier to call plays when you have Derrick Henry at RB. Henry ran for over 2000 yards last season and that’s an even more impressive feat considering everyone knows he’s getting the ball. It might be helpful if the team could find a solid backup but Darryton Evans has injury issues, Jeremy McNichols hasn’t really impressed and their best option is undrafted rookie Mekhi Sargent, he made the team out of camp. The offensive line has been built to be a run blocking unit and they have four of five spots pretty well set. LT Taylor Lewan is a perfect fit. LG Roger Saffold is aging but still effective. C Ben Jones isn’t flashy but he’s intelligent. RG Nate Davis is young and developing. The RT spot is the one question mark. Veterans Kendall Lamm and Ty Sambrailo battled and for now it looks like Sambrailo won.
The passing game took a hit when Jonnu Smith left in free agency for New England. He had taken the place of Delanie Walker as Tannehill’s most trusted target and now Tannehill doesn’t have proven TE to use. Geoff Swaim steps in as the blocker while the team hopes Anthony Firkser can build on a solid season behind Smith last year as the pass catcher. WR Corey Davis left in free agency also and the team traded for Julio Jones. At the top of his game Jones is a massive upgrade over Davis but Jones is 32 and coming off an injury plagued year in Atlanta. He’s been banged up in the preseason and that’s not a great sign. Jones doesn’t have to be the #1 WR as AJ Brown has proven to be a Tannehill favorite. Brown is a bulldog, he plays everywhere, he’s not afraid to go over the middle and he’s tough as nails. He fits perfectly in the Titans’ gritty offense. The team really needs Josh Reynolds to step up as the third receiver. They don’t have much after him on the depth chart and with their lack of a playmaking TE they could really use a good slot receiver. This is a team that will certainly be looking at the waiver wire at WR come cutdown day. At TE too.
The Titans’ defense struggled last season and it was mostly to do with the lack of pass rush. They run a 3-4 defense and generally that doesn’t generate a lot of pass rush from the defensive line but the team signed Denico Autry from Indianapolis because he can play end in a 3-4 and still get to the QB. He should pair nicely with Jeffrey Simmons who might actually be the best player on this defense. For now, Teair Tart is the starter at the NT, he’s the major question mark up front. The bigger free agent addition is Bud Dupree at OLB, he’s coming off a knee injury but he had eight sacks in 11 games for the Steelers last year, that’s what the Titans need. They hope having Dupree on one side will also help free up Harold Landry on the other and really juice the pass rush. Jayon Brown and Rashaan Evans are a solid duo inside, they clean up in the tackling department. They will need the defensive line to hold up inside to keep them clean, that could be an issue.
The secondary is undergoing a massive overhaul with only FS Kevin Byard a returning starter. Byard is a very good safety but he had 111 tackles last season and you never want your last level of defense having to make that many tackles. Amani Hooker moves into the SS spot after being a bit of a jack-of-all-trades in the secondary the last few years. He’s a playmaker, they need that. The team lost Adoree Jackson and Malcolm Butler at CB, that’s not a bad thing. Janoris Jenkins will be 33 this year but he should still be decent as one starter. For now, Kristian Fulton looks like the other starter after starting twice last year. The real hope is that rookie Caleb Farley can be healthy after back surgery earlier this year. Farley is a supreme talent that they drafted in round one but the back issues are concerning. Farley has #1 CB ability, something this team hasn’t had in quite a while.
Indianapolis Colts
This team is gambling at a couple of key spots on the offense and so far, it’s not going well. They made a major trade to bring in Carson Wentz at QB to take over for the retired Phillip Rivers. They believe Frank Reich can fix whatever went wrong with Wentz in Philadelphia but Wentz got hurt already. Even if he gets back to start the season, they still have to fix him. The other spot is LT. Anthony Costanzo retired and the team didn’t do much until they signed Eric Fisher from Kansas City. He tore his Achilles in January during the AFC Championship game and now the Colts are counting on a 30-year-old to recover from an Achilles tear in about nine months, that’s a tough ask. They took an even bigger hit on the line when LG Quenton Nelson suffered the same foot injury that knocked Wentz out. He’s the best guard in the league and they need him, he may be back to start the year too but he likely won’t be 100%. Center Ryan Kelly is also dealing with an elbow injury so things are off to a rocky start for the Colts. The right side of the line has RT Braden Smith and RB Mark Glowinski, they are steady players the team can count on.
They are solid at the skill positions. RB Jonathan Taylor looks poised to be one of the better RB in the league and he’s not alone in the backfield. Marlon Mack is a very talented player and Nyheim Hines is a heck of a third down threat. Even Jordan Wilkins is a solid runner. TY Hilton was hoping for a bounce back season but he’s injured and was placed on IR, not a great start. The team seems to have confidence that both Michael Pittman Jr and Parris Campbell are young players ready to step up, they better hope so. Zach Pascal isn’t flashy but he’s a solid fourth receiver who will likely start with Hilton out. TEs Jack Doyle and Mo Alie-Cox are not household names but they are professional TEs who get the job done.
The defense plays better than they look on paper. Defensive coordinator Matt Eberflus seems to know what buttons to push and what plays to call. They lost Denico Autry up front and Justin Houston as one of their better pass rushers. They drafted Kwity Paye to step in and he should be solid. Veterans Tyquan Lewis and Kemoko Turay need to step up and provide more playmaking at DE. DeForest Buckner was a costly addition last year but he paid off in a major way. He may not have quite the same statistical impact this year but his presence makes everyone better. Grover Stewart starts inside next to Buckner and he’s an underrated talent.
The LB corps starts with Darius Leonard, he’s now one of the highest paid LBs in the NFL and rightfully so. He’s a dynamic playmaker they rely on heavily. He will miss the steady Anthony Walker at MLB but the team likes youngster Bobby Okereke there and they couldn’t afford to pay both Walker and Leonard, they made the right choice. Zaire Franklin is the other young guy they like; they hope he holds up on the opposite side of Leonard.
The secondary is surprisingly good and isn’t full of names anyone knows. Xavier Rhodes looked done a couple of years ago in Minnesota but he’s steady for the Colts. Rock Ya-Sin is the other outside guy and while he’s not great he isn’t bad. Kenny Moore is the nickel back and he’s arguably the best one in the league. FS Justin Blackmon is underrated for now, he’s pretty good. SS Khari Willis is holding down that spot for now.
Jacksonville Jaguars
It’s Trevor Lawrence’s franchise now. The Jaguars were extra bad at just the right time and had the #1 pick when a generational QB was on the board, now they have to try to not screw it up. They are off to a rocky start with an offensive line that has looked terrible in the preseason. They inexplicably franchised LT Cam Robinson and he’s not worth the price. LG Andrew Norwell and RG AJ Cann should be better but they will both be 30 this year and seem to be struggling. C Brandon Linder is the best of the bunch but he can’t do it all himself. RT Jawaan Taylor is still a young, promising player that Urban Meyer and his coaching staff have to get to reach his potential. They did draft Walker Little but I’m not sure he’s ready to step in at LT just yet.
The good news for Lawrence is that the Jaguars have done a solid job of adding skill position players for him to work with, with the exception of the TE spot (and no that’s not a shot at Tim Tebow, he’s already gone). At WR, DJ Chark is a physically gifted player who has #1 WR potential with a QB like Trevor Lawrence throwing to him. Marvin Jones is a strong veteran #2 WR that Lawrence can count on. Laviska Shenault is a fantastic offensive weapon they need to find ways to use. RB James Robinson was a fantastic find last year and he can carry the load. Carlos Hyde was brought in to do some of the short yardage work and take some of the wear and tear off of Robinson. Travis Etienne was drafted in round one to give Lawrence a familiar face and give this offense a guy with some big play potential. Unfortunately, Etienne got injured and he’s out for the season. Calling the TE group non-descript is underselling it, they aren’t likely to help much, Seriously, I’m not even looking up their names. Urban Meyer and offensive coordinator Darrell Bevell have their work cut out for them with a suspect offensive line and rookie QB but there is finally some light at the end of the tunnel for Jaguars fans.
Joe Cullen was hired as Meyer’s defensive coordinator coming over from Baltimore. The team will transition from a 4-3 to a 3-4 base like the Ravens and while their will be some growing pains, some of the talent actually fits the new defense better. Free agent signee Roy Robertson-Harris comes over from Chicago and they traded for Malcolm Brown from New Orleans and both guys have history as 3-4 ends. DaVon Hamilton should be fine at NT but the team doesn’t have much depth there.
Josh Allen and K’Lavon Chaisson were both first round picks and while Allen played well at DE he should be even better as an OLB. Chaisson was miscast as a DE and has a better shot at becoming useful as a pass rushing OLB. At ILB the team has Myles Jack, he’s versatile enough to play in any defense so he should be fine. They traded Joe Schobert, their big defensive free agent from last season, to Pittsburgh and they are slotting Damien Wilson in next to Jack. Wilson gives them a good, athletic player inside, he’ll be fine.
The secondary is undergoing quite an overhaul. The team signed CB Shaquill Griffin and drafted Tyson Campbell and it looked like last year’s top pick, CJ Henderson was on the outs with the new coaching staff. He may have gotten himself back in their good graces and should be a useful player, for now. They have veteran Tre Herndon if they need depth. FS Rashawn Jenkins was signed to give the backend a playmaker. I don’t know who is starting at SS. Andrew Wingard or Rudy Ford could get the job but I’m looking at rookie Andre Cisco to eventually take it. Joe Cullen spent some good years learning in Baltimore but the transition from a 4-3 to a 3-4 can be rough, luckily there’s really nowhere to go but up for this team.
Houston Texans
The Texans’ dumpster fire starts at QB. The team has no idea what is happening with Deshaun Watson. He’s under criminal investigation for sexual assault, he’s being sued for it, the league is investigating and amongst all that he still wants to be traded. Yeah, no one is trading for him. Watson doesn’t trust the owner, no one likes their Executive Vice President of Football Operations, Jack Easterby, and they hired a 65-year-old first time head coach, David Culley, a guy no one else was considering for a head coaching job. Their new GM is Nick Caserio, he came over from New England and is trying to put a roster together during all of this. It’s a tire fire, inside of a dumpster, in the middle of a hurricane, during a pandemic (the last part, literally).
Tyrod Taylor will start at QB, which probably means this team is going to draft a QB in the top 5 in 2022 and Taylor will lose his job to him. Watson ends up in Denver, Pittsburgh, Green Bay or prison next year, it’s a pick ‘em. The team traded DeAndre Hopkins last year for RB David Johnson and then proceeded to sign Mark Ingram, Phillip Lindsay and Rex Burkhead at RB. The running game has options. Brandin Cooks is the #1 WR and they traded for Anthony Miller, who underachieved in Chicago. They signed Chris Conley and they like rookie Nico Collins, it’s not a great group of receivers, but it’s not the worst part of the team. They aren’t great at TE but rookie Brevin Jordan could be a guy eventually.
The offensive line features one of the best LTs in football, Laremy Tunsil. It’s like having diamond encrusted spinners on a Pinto. The rest of the line is rough. Max Scharping is the LG, he’s okay. They are counting on Justin Britt to resurrect his career at center after being hurt, opting out of last season and trying to come back at 30. Tytus Howard is supposed to be the RT but the team traded for Marcus Cannon from the Patriots so maybe he starts there and Howard moves inside. Or Cannon moves inside, except Cannon really isn’t a guard, neither is Howard really. Roster construction is a bit rough in Houston. Four RBs, 1 WR, no TEs, two RTs, no RG and Tyrod Taylor is your QB. Maybe Davis Mills will save the day.
If you thought the offense was rough, you might want to skip this next part. The defense is moving from a 3-4, which they have been for a very long time, to a 4-3 with Lovie Smith coming in as the defensive coordinator (at least they have a ready-made interim when this Culley thing goes bad). Whitney Mercilus moves from OLB to DE, he’s the best pass rusher they have, that’s not a complement. They signed Jordan Jenkins from the Jets and he’s moving from OLB to DE and the Jets haven’t rushed the passer in years. They traded for Shaq Lawson from the Dolphins because he was so bad the Dolphins wanted him gone, he had just as many sacks for Miami as Mercilus had leading the Texans. Then they shipped Lawson to the Jets. Maliek Collins starts at one DT spot after a tough year in Vegas. Journeyman Vincent Taylor gets the other DT spot, they really need to hope Ross Blacklock can rebound after a tough rookie season.
At LB, the news is a little better. Zach Cunningham is extremely productive and Lovie Smith has coached some really good LBs, he should be able to get the best out of Cunningham. At MLB they traded Bernardrick McKinney in the Lawson deal and signed Christian Kirksey. Kirksey has had three injury riddled years in a row and it’s hard to count on him giving you much. If he’s healthy, he’s fine, he’s rarely healthy anymore. Kevin Pierre-Louis is set to be the other starter, whoever that is.
Terrance Mitchell and Bradley Roby were supposed to be the starting CBs until today, when the Texans traded Roby to the Saints. Desmond King was supposed to be the nickel corner but now he gets promoted to full-time starter. Mitchell is not great and King is looking to rebound from a few down years after his two good years with the Chargers to start his career. King hasn’t been a full-time starting outside CB since his days at Iowa but this is an opportunity for him to show what he can do. SS Eric Murray is a solid professional but FS Justin Reid is arguably the best player on this defense (and only Cunningham at his best has an argument). Reid is coming to the end of his rookie deal and if he plays well, he could bolt in free agency. Lovie Smith’s career as a head coach hasn’t always been great and it certainly has ended badly in a few spots but he’s an excellent defensive mind. This defense doesn’t have a lot to work with so he has his work cut out for him but he should get the best out of Cunningham, Reid, King and maybe some others. For any Texans fans out there just remember these words, With the First Pick in the 2022 NFL Draft, the Houston Texans select…