AFC South Draft Review
Houston continued their off season of making us all ask, “what the hell was that?”. They better hope their moves in free agency and the trade market work because other than Ross Blacklock there isn’t much help here. The Colts continued an off season of making moves to put them in a position to challenge for the division this season and if things go right, a deep playoff run. They got a WR and a RB to help Phillip Rivers course correct the offense right away. Jacksonville is throwing a lot at the wall to see what sticks. They need help and I think David Caldwell did a good job of getting them some. The Titans didn’t do a lot in the draft but they may have done enough to keep up in the division. They filled some really big holes at RT and CB. That’s going to go a long way to keeping them moving forward.
Houston Texans
(40) Ross Blacklock DL TCU
(90) Jonathan Greenard OLB Florida
(126) Charlie Heck OT UNC
(141) John Reid CB Penn St.
(171) Isaiah Coulter WR Rhode Island
Immediate Impact: DL Ross Blacklock
The Houston Texans have had one of the most heavily criticized off seasons in quite some time, one smart move they made was getting Blacklock. He’s a potential starter on the defensive line because the guys not named JJ Watt are replaceable. He may not take over immediately, especially if training camp is shortened or delayed, he has some work to do. However, he’s a talented guy who can fit in a few different ways. Watt will appreciate the help.
Best Value: None
The team essentially got players about where they were rated. Blacklock could have gone slightly higher but he was pretty much seen as a top half of round two guy and that’s where he went.
Sleeper: CB John Reid
The Texans have a couple of reclamation projects on one-year contracts behind Bradley Roby at CB. Vernon Hargreaves breathed some life into his career after he was cut from the Bucs last season and signed with Houston while Gareon Conley came over in a trade but didn’t have his fifth-year option picked up. That means the Texans aren’t sold on either one. Reid isn’t big, or long, or flashy but the guy started 40 games at Penn St. and he can play. He will likely end up a slot corner because of his size but he can make a move into that position pretty quickly on this roster.
Overall Analysis
You can’t evaluate the Texans draft without talking about their other moves because those moves affected the draft. The team traded their first-round pick for Laremy Tunsil and while he cost them a fortune with his new contract, he does give them a LT to protect Deshaun Watson for the foreseeable future. They gave up their second-round pick for WR Brandin Cooks, a trade made necessary by them trading Deandre Hopkins for a second-round pick and RB David Johnson. Essentially trading Hopkins for Cook and Johnson, not a great move. There were other picks involved in these trades that left them short of a full allotment of picks. Of the five picks they did make, Blacklock was a good choice who fills an immediate need. OLB Jonathan Greenard is a guy that looks the part getting off the bus but he’s highly inconsistent. If the Texans can harness his potential, he can be a great addition opposite Whitney Mercilus but that’s a tall task. OT Charlie Heck is a long, lean prospect with great reach but he has a long way to go with his technique and physicality. Solid prospect but with Laremy Tunsil and Tyus Howard around the Texans better hope they don’t need him.
Indianapolis Colts
(34) Michael Pittman Jr. WR USC
(41) Jonathan Taylor RB Wisconsin
(85) Julian Blackmon S Utah
(122) Jacob Eason QB Washington
(149) Danny Pinter OL Ball St.
(193) Robert Windsor DL Penn St.
(211) Isaiah Rodgers CB UMass
(212) Dezmon Patmon WR Washington St.
(213) Jordan Glasgow LB Michigan
Immediate Impact: WR Michael Pittman, RB Jonathan Taylor
The team had no first-round pick after trading it but they had two second-round picks and they hit both of them out of the park. Pittman is a big WR who plays like a big WR and he’s quite the technician, he should be a perfect outside complement to TY Hilton. He’s also the type of WR new QB Phillip Rivers loves. Taylor was the best RB in the draft in my opinion and they stole in at 41st overall. They have Marlon Mack but you won’t convince me Taylor isn’t going to be a monster behind the Colts excellent offensive line, it doesn’t matter how many touches he gets.
Best Value: RB Jonathan Taylor
Taylor is a future star and he gives the team a great 1-2 punch at RB behind a fantastic offensive line and for an offense with an aging QB. Rivers still has plenty of game but he will be a much more effective player with a great running game to lean on. Taylor is a work horse, he proved that in college. That heavy workload from college may end up meaning he has a shortened pro career but this team is primed to win now and Taylor can play day one. He should have been a first-round pick, getting him at 41st overall was a steal.
Sleeper: QB Jacob Eason
The Colts went for the short play signing Phillip Rivers to a one-year contract to take over a team that could be very good with some better QB play. They backed that up by taking a chance on Jacob Eason in round four, a QB with elite physical skills who needs some time to grow. Eason can throw it a mile but he’s not a great athlete. He needs to learn the nuances of the QB position and there are not a lot of guys in the NFL with more playing time under their best than Rivers. Rivers even plans to go into coaching after his playing days are over, he can start this year by bringing Eason along as a QB.
Overall Analysis
The Colts roster is actually in pretty good shape both with starters and with the backups. They traded their first-round pick to get DL DeForest Buckner which fills a huge need. Then in round two they got one starter and one potential starter in Pittman and Taylor. Throw in the fact they signed Phillip Rivers at QB and this team found four key players that will improve the team dramatically. The team isn’t exactly stacked at safety so Julian Blackmon is a guy with great versatility who could be quite useful. Eason has lottery ticket potential but he’s at least a year away from seeing the field and it would probably be better if it were two or three years down the line. Danny Pinter and Robert Windsor are two guys who could offer depth on the offensive and defensive lines respectively. The last three picks are going to have a hard time making the Colts’ roster, like I said the team is in pretty good shape overall. The Colts had a pretty good off season and this draft was just the capper.
Jacksonville Jaguars
(9) CJ Henderson CB Florida
(20) K’Lavon Chaisson DE/OLB LSU
(42) Laviska Shenault Jr. WR Colorado
(73) Davon Hamilton DL Ohio St
(116) Ben Bartch OT St. John’s (MN)
(137) Josiah Scott CB Michigan St.
(140) Shaquille Quarterman LB Miami
(157) Daniel Thomas S Auburn
(165) Collin Johnson WR Texas
(189) Jake Luton QB Oregon St.
(206) Tyler Davis TE Georgia Tech
(223) Chris Claybrooks CB Memphis
Immediate Impact: CB CJ Henderson, DE K’Lavon Chaisson
The first day Henderson walks onto the practice field he’s immediately the best cover corner on the team. The Jags traded away Jalen Ramsey and AJ Bouye and that leaves a huge hole in the secondary. Henderson is an elite coverage player, he’s not a great tackler, the Jaguars understand what they are getting and they will work with it. Chaisson is actually a maybe on being an immediate impact player. The team franchised Yannick Ngakoue and he doesn’t want to return. If he relents, he teams with Josh Allen at DE, if he doesn’t and they trade him, Chaisson becomes much more important.
Best Value: WR Laviska Shenault Jr.
Shenault was a dynamic weapon at Colorado all over the field. He lined up at WR, RB and even as a wildcat QB. He has elite after-the-catch skills and he only fell to the second round because he had a core-muscle injury he had to have surgically repaired after the combine. The only reason I didn’t list him as immediate impact is because of his rehab from surgery interfering with his ability to overtake some the veterans on the Jaguars. If he was 100% healthy, I would say he has a chance to take out either Chris Conley or Dede Westbrook as a starter opposite DJ Chark.
Sleeper: CB Josiah Scott
The team has veterans Rashaan Melvin, DJ Hayden and Tre Herndon lined up behind rookie CJ Henderson, that’s not the greatest lineup and Scott has a chance to make a move. He’s probably best suited to be a nickel back and I think he has a good shot of taking that spot pretty early. That would make two rookies out of their top three CBs but the Jaguars are in a rebuild so I don’t think they would mind.
Overall Analysis
The Jaguars are ready to go into the season with Gardner Minshew leading the way, if Minshew Mania fails, they will be in a good position to take one of the top QBs next year. They are building a solid offense and they are trying to rebuild their defense. Henderson and Chaisson fill needs, Henderson fills the biggest one at CB. I don’t actually like Chaisson as a prospect, for me he’s too much athletic flash and not enough football player. I love the Shenault pick, that kid will make plays and do it all over the field. He makes a really nice complement to DJ Chark. Davon Hamilton isn’t the flashy guy but he brings one thing the team can use, size up the middle, he’s 6’4 320 lbs. He will make life easier for undersized DT Taven Bryant and new MLB Joe Schobert. OT Ben Bartch was a solid gamble trying to find an OT to develop. I like the Josiah Scott pick quite a bit and while LB Shaquille Quarterman doesn’t wow you he gives them LB depth and should be good on special teams. The team had twelve draft picks, that’s a lot and it’s very difficult for that many rookies to make a roster. They did draft to try to find some depth at positions of need with a safety, Daniel Thomas, and a CB Chris Claybrooks. If you’re going to take a shot it might as well be at your weakest position. WR Collin Johnson looks like Calvin Johnson getting off the bus since he’s 6’6 220 lbs. Unfortunately, when he plays, he is not like him at all. He can high-point the ball but he’s 6’6 so that should be a given. He doesn’t separate well at all. They drafted TE Tyler Davis who is raw and I’m not sure he can be very productive; the team might be better off trying to bulk up Collin Johnson and make him a move TE. The choice of QB Jake Luton is strange since the team signed Mike Glennon to replace Nick Foles as the backup and they still have Josh Dobbs. I’m not sure drafting a poor-man’s Mike Glennon as a development QB for the practice squad was necessary.
Tennessee Titans
(29) Isaiah Wilson OT Georgia
(61) Kristian Fulton CB LSU
(93) Darrynton Evans RB Appalachian St.
(174) Larrell Murchison DL North Carolina St.
(224) Cole McDonald QB Hawaii
(243) Chris Jackson CB Marshall
Immediate Impact: OT Isaiah Wilson
There might not be a better player to scheme fit in the first round of the draft or maybe the whole draft than Isaiah Wilson going to the Titans. Wilson is mammoth human being who absolutely mauls defenders in the run game. The team lost RT Jack Conklin in free agency and Wilson is a ready-made replacement. Derrick Henry is a power back and he shouldn’t miss a beat running behind Wilson, unless his 6’6 350 lbs. frame makes it take longer for Henry to run around him.
Best Value: CB Kristian Fulton
I had Fulton as a first-round pick and he damn near fell out of the second round. He has starter potential and as much as I will always love Malcolm Butler for his interception in the Super Bowl, he better watch his back. Fulton can take the starting job from Butler and at the very least he’s the third CB very early. That’s incredible value for the 61st pick.
Sleeper: RB Darryton Evans
This team likes to run the ball but Derrick Henry was used way too much last season and the team doesn’t even have a veteran like Dion Lewis around anymore. That leaves a big, giant hole behind Henry and Evans should fill it nicely. He’s a strong runner who has a little different skill set than Henry and that could help the offense. He can come in and take some of the weight off of Henry which should help keep him fresh.
Overall Analysis
The Titans started out well with three good picks. Wilson fills their biggest hole on offense after they couldn’t afford to keep Conklin with the re-signing of Ryan Tannehill and franchising Derrick Henry. Fulton was such a great pick at the end of round two considering his value and the team’s need for help at CB. Evans is a sneaky good pick; he wasn’t a household name but he’s a highly effective RB. DL Larrell Murchison gives them depth on the defensive line. QB Cole McDonald is a guy with a live arm and good accuracy who makes some bad decisions but they are only bringing him in to compete for the backup spot. Logan Woodside is his competition so the job isn’t guaranteed to anyone. Chris Jackson is an instinctive CB who needs to eat a cheeseburger or two. At 186 lbs. he’s going to get pushed around in the NFL, for his sake he better hope an NFL training regiment can bulk him up a bit. He’s probably looking at a rookie year on the practice squad.