NFL Coaching Carousel

The NFL took the crazy season to a new level with John Harbaugh getting fired by the Ravens after 18 seasons and Mike Tomlin walking away from the Steelers after 19 years.  These were the two longest tenured coaches in the league, and both are Super Bowl winners.  Add them to two-time winning Coach of the Year Kevin Stefanski in Cleveland and the only AFC North coach coming back next year is Zac Taylor in Cincinnati.  Taylor could have been fired but the Bengals don’t like to fire coaches with time left on their contracts so Taylor will be on the firing line next year.

There will be nine new head coaches next year, that’s a lot.  It’s almost always somewhere between 5-8 each off season so nine is on the high side, although it’s not unheard of.  The jobs are the New York Giants, Baltimore Ravens, Pittsburgh Steelers, Atlanta Falcons, Miami Dolphins, Tennessee Titans, Las Vegas Raiders, Cleveland Browns, and Arizona Cardinals.  I’ll take a look here at each job and give you some thoughts on who’s up for the job, who I would recommend, and my prediction for each opening.  At the end I’ll throw in some thoughts on some coordinator openings that are intriguing.  Let’s dive in.

New York Giants

Out: Brian Daboll-fired in season

In: John Harbaugh-finalizing a deal

The Giants wasted no time getting Harbaugh in for an interview and they are moving fast.  With Mike Tomlin looking to take at least a year off, Harbaugh is the top candidate for pretty much everyone and he was just deciding where to interview.  The Giants are a good job with QB Jaxson Dart, RB Cam Skattebo, WR Malik Nabers, LT Andrew Thomas, DT Dexter Lawrence, Edge rushers Adbul Carter and Brian Burns, and some other young talent on defense.  Having QB, WR, LT, DT, and DE looking good means your team is off to a good start.  It will be interesting to see how it shakes out with GM Joe Schoen, who has been retained so far, and a new coach with as much leverage as Harbaugh has. 

The luck may have turned for the Giants because they have had a series of misses at head coach and were looking at another tough coaching search without a great list of candidates until Ravens owner Steve Bisciotti gifted them Harbaugh.  Maybe they would have ended up with Stefanski but no one has the resume of Harbaugh at this point (since Tomlin’s not taking a job).

My Recommendation: Definitely would have been Harbaugh.

My Prediction: None, Harbaugh already has the job.

Baltimore Ravens

Out: John Harbaugh

Top Candidates: Jesse Minter, Anthony Weaver, Kevin Stefanski, Jim Schwartz, Brian Flores, Klint Kubiak, Vance Joseph

With Harbaugh gone and likely taking OC Todd Monken with him to New York, this is a complete reboot of the coaching staff.  The Ravens have been built on their defense for a long time and have had some excellent defensive coaches who have moved elsewhere.  Mike Macdonald is the one that got away as he’s the head coach in Seattle now.  If they are looking for someone similar, Jesse Minter is that guy.  Minter is the Chargers DC and he’s been awesome.  He’s still young at 42 but he has great experience.  He coached for the Ravens as a defensive assistant, was also the National Championship winning DC under Jim Harbaugh at Michigan, and now has had two excellent years running the Chargers defense. 

Anthony Weaver is another coach who spent time on the defensive staff for the Ravens before he took over the Dolphins defense a couple years ago. People rave about Weaver as a leader and he once served as the Assistant Head Coach of the Ravens for John Harbaugh.  Weaver also worked with Mike Vrabel when Vrabel was in Houston.  Minter and Weaver should be at the top of the Ravens list because they know the team, they understand the culture, and they are two guys who have earned their shot. 

Kevin Stefanski is an excellent coach who’s been in a horrible situation.  Jim Schwartz has been a great defensive coordinator for a long time in the NFL.  So has Brian Flores and he deserves another shot.  Vance Joseph is coordinating the best defense in the league and he’s worthy too. 

My Recommendation: Hire Minter, he can keep the culture while making the right changes.

My Prediction: Jesse Minter – The Ravens regret letting Mike Macdonald get away, Minter is the closest they get to him. 

Pittsburgh Steelers

Out: Mike Tomlin

Top Candidates: Brian Flores, Chris Shula, Kevin Stefanski, Nate Scheelhaase, Anthony Weaver, Ejiro Evero

The Steelers don’t do this very often, only 3 coaches since 1969.  When they hired Bill Cowher and when they hired Tomlin, those weren’t hot coaching candidates, they were just the guys they liked the best in the interview room.  That makes this tough because we aren’t in the room to see what they see.  Their list has some young and intriguing choices like Chris Shula and Nate Scheelhaase from the Rams.  Shula, the grandson of the great Don Shula has been Sean McVay’s DC for the past two seasons and he’s been excellent.  After the team lost Aaron Donald to retirement and Jalen Ramsey left, everyone expected a downturn, it didn’t happen.  Shula is a bright, young defensive mind.  Nate Scheelhaase is the passing game coordinator for Sean McVay’s Rams and he’s seen as an up-and-comer.  He’s only been an NFL coach for two seasons, he came from being Iowa St.’s OC to work with McVay.  He could blow them away in the process. 

Stefanski, again is an excellent coach but probably not their guy.  Anthony Weaver might have some of that Tomlin interview energy and that also goes for Evero.  Neither one of them coordinated elite defenses this year but it is more about them as leaders than X’s and O’s guys.  Flores spent a year coaching LBs for Tomlin after he left Miami and so there is some familiarity to the organization.

My Recommendation: Anthony Weaver. He feels like a guy who could keep the Tomlin culture going but give it a refresh. 

My Prediction: Chris Shula-he just feels like the type of young guy they will like. 

Atlanta Falcons

Out: Raheem Morris

Top Candidates: Jeff Hafley, Mike McDaniel, Kevin Stefanski, Klint Kubiak, Anthony Weaver, Aden Durde

The Falcons are starting the whole thing over with Matt Ryan being hired to be President of Football Operations and he’s in charge of hiring a new GM and head coach.  I’m not sure where he’s leaning at GM but he could have some strong feelings on head coach. Jeff Hafley coached at Boston College and Matt Ryan is an alumnus.  They weren’t there at the same time but certainly Ryan knows Hafley.  Ryan did cross paths with Mike McDaniel who was an offensive assistant for the Falcons when Ryan was the QB.  Ryan had his most success under Kyle Shanahan and that’s who McDaniel worked under before being a head coach.  McDaniel also would have crossed paths with Jeff Ulbrich in Atlanta when they were both assistants.  The Falcons would like to keep Ulbrich as their DC and McDaniel may be open to that.

Stefanski is going to be up for most jobs so I’m mentioning him here.  He isn’t connected to Ryan but his offense would work for the Falcons.  Klint Kubiak is a hot OC who could get a job and he runs the Shanahan offense too.  Weaver is a guy well liked in the league and well respected in coaching circles.  Aden Durde is a new name for most but he’s the DC in Seattle under Mike Macdonald so his name is going to keep coming up. 

My Recommendation: Mike McDaniel, if anyone is going to save Michael Penix as a franchise QB, it’s him.

My Prediction: Mike McDaniel- I just can’t get the fit with Ryan and with Ulbrich out of my mind. The only question is will McDaniel like the idea of Michael Penix at QB.  If he doesn’t, he’s the most overqualified OC candidate for the top teams looking for an OC. 

Miami Dolphins

Out: Mike McDaniel

Top Candidates: Jeff Hafley, Kevin Stefanski, Robert Saleh, Joe Brady, Anthony Campanile, Chris Shula

The Dolphins fired GM Chris Grier during the season and then waited a few extra days after then end of the season to fire Mike McDaniel.  The firing coincided with the Ravens firing John Harbaugh and felt like a reaction to it and many assumed owner Stephen Ross might make a play for Harbaugh.  That didn’t happen and he hired Jon-Eric Sullivan as GM from Green Bay.  Sullivan was in Green Bay a long time and so he has connections to current Packers DC Jeff Hafley and former Packers defensive assistant Anthony Campanile.  Hafley might just have a leg up here because of that but Campanile has really impressed this year as the Jaguars DC.  It could be a dogfight between the two of them.  This isn’t the most attractive job because you have to figure out the QB situation with Tua. 

Stefanski, yep he’s still here and is a solid candidate.  Saleh is a guy who really rehabbed his coaching stock by taking the MASH unit that is San Fransico’s defense and doing quite well.  He made people remember what made him such a great coach before the Jets fiasco.  Joe Brady hasn’t gotten a lot of requests to interview and it may be because the Bills are still playing.  I’m throwing Chris Shula in here but I wouldn’t think he would want to take his first head coaching job where his grandfather was such a legend, that’s a lot to ask. 

My Recommendation: Jeff Hafley, he seems ready for the move and as long as he finds an OC, he should be good.

My Prediction: Jeff Hafley- It feels like he’s going to get a job this cycle and this is the best chance he has at one.  The connection to Sullivan wins out. 

Tennessee Titans

Out: Brian Callahan

Top Candidates: Kevin Stefanski, Arthur Smith, Klint Kubiak, Matt Nagy, Mike McCarthy, Mike McDaniel

The Titans are in a unique position because it feels like they want an offensive mind to coach Cam Ward.  The defensive coordinator group is better stocked with young talent than the offensive side so it’s a different search.  Stefanski and McDaniel are the best offensive minds available this cycle and the Titans may luck out that the better jobs will be filled by defensive candidates.  Stefanski would be an excellent fit and he would love the idea of having his QB and it not being Deshaun Watson.  McDaniel could also do wonders with Ward. 

Arthur Smith was the Steelers OC but the best work in his career was as the OC of the Titans when Mike Vrabel was the coach, the ownership group hasn’t forgotten him.  Matt Nagy has a connection to GM Mike Borgonzi who used to be in Kansas City.  I can’t see a team with a young QB going with Nagy after his time in Chicago. Also, the Titans are going to be opening a new stadium and Matt Nagy is not the name they need selling tickets.  Klint Kubiak is an excellent young offensive mind but I’m not sure he’s up for this job.

My Recommendation: Kevin Stefanski, they would be lucky to get such a good coach after firing Mike Vrabel and whiffing on Brian Callahan. 

My Prediction: Kevin Stefanski- he’s such a good coach and here he gets to build out his offense around a QB he might actually like.  The Titans get lucky that the Giants got Harbaugh and Ravens going with a guy they know well.  This is a good match. 

Las Vegas Raiders

Out: Pete Carroll

Top Candidates: Brian Flores, Vance Joseph, Jesse Minter, Ejiro Evero, Davis Webb, Klint Kubiak

The Raiders are hiring a coach again, it’s a yearly ritual in Sin City.  There was an early rumor that Tom Brady wants Brian Flores and to bring in Brian Daboll as his offensive coordinator, that would be way too good for this franchise.  They haven’t had competent coaching like that since Jon Gruden…the first time.  They are looking at the usual suspects at this point.  Vance Joseph, Jesse Minter, and Ejiro Evero are defensive coordinators who deserve a shot, or a second shot in Joseph’s case.  Kubiak is the offensive mind a lot of teams are kicking the tires on.  The one outside the box idea is Davis Webb.  Webb was a backup/third-string QB in the league not long ago and he’s only 30.  Currently, he’s Sean Payton’s QB coach in Denver but he’s a guy on the fast track.  The potential pairing of Vance Joseph as head coach and Webb as the OC would make some sense too.  They are both currently on the Broncos staff. 

My Recommendation: Move heaven and earth to convince Brian Flores to take the head job and for Brian Daboll to be his offensive coordinator.

My Prediction: They will screw this up.  That’s my prediction, they will screw this up.  Unless Brady can pull off the Flores/Daboll thing, this could go badly.  I’ll pick Flores for now but more likely they hire Webb without getting him some help to fix the o-line or they hire Evero and he can’t get a decent OC which will screw him over. 

Cleveland Browns

Out: Kevin Stefanski

Top Candidates: Mike McDaniel, Grant Udinski, Tommy Rees, Jim Schwartz, Nate Scheelhaase, Dan Pitcher

The Browns are clearly looking for a young offensive coordinator type who doesn’t understand how bad this job is.  Their preferred candidate is Mike McDaniel because at least he’s been a head coach.  Grant Udinski (Jaguars), Tommy Rees (Browns), Nate Scheelhaase (Rams), and Dan Pitcher (Bengals) are all young offensive guys who are some sort of coordinator (Scheelhaase is the passing game coordinator, the others are OC) for play calling head coaches.  Jim Schwartz has been the Browns awesome DC but he was a failed head coach once and hasn’t gotten a second shot.  None of these young coaches should take this job as their first job, they can all wait for a better opportunity.  McDaniel is said to be thinking about taking a good OC job instead of one of the bad head coach jobs (that would be the Browns, Cardinals, and maybe the Raiders he would be avoiding).

My Recommendation: When they strike out on the young OCs they should promote Schwartz and then make Rees the play calling OC.  This team is in transition and I’m not sure any hire is a long-term thing. 

My Prediction: Mike McCarthy- Once the Browns strike out on all of these guys, including McDaniel taking the OC job with the Eagles or Lions or someone like that, they pivot.  McCarthy is looking for a third chance at a head coaching job, he wouldn’t object to Jim Schwartz staying on as defensive coordinator, and at least he’s willing to do the job. 

Arizona Cardinals

Out: Jonathan Gannon

Top Candidates: Vance Joseph, Robert Saleh, Arthur Smith, Thomas Brown, Matt Burke, Klint Kubiak

The Cardinals fired Jonathan Gannon and rightfully so but there were only expected to be maybe five openings at the time, instead there are nine.  The Cardinals are at the bottom of the pecking order with the Browns.  The Kyler Murray situation at QB is murky at best, the offensive line needs an overhaul, and the team has been bad for a while.  Vance Joseph was an excellent defensive coordinator for them at one time, so his name is here.  Robert Saleh would be a guy to bring a complete change from the personality of Jonathan Gannon.  Gannon had a reputation for being an odd duck and not much of a motivator, Saleh is the exact opposite. 

Arthur Smith has ties to the Titans organization and GM Monti Ossenfort was with the Titans for a time.  Thomas Brown is with the Patriots but he’s been with a few organizations and has a lot of fans in the league.  He may not get a head coaching job this cycle but I think he’s a likely OC for one of the better OC openings in the league.  Matt Burke is the DC in Houston and has been an excellent DC who doesn’t get as much credit as he should because his head coach DeMeco Ryans is a defensive guy.  Burke calls that defense and should get more credit.  Kubiak could be the guy here, but he might be better off passing on this job and staying Seattle’s OC if he can’t do better.

My Recommendation: Anthony Weaver or Robert Saleh.  Jonathan Gannon was such a strange personality this team needs to think about getting a more dynamic football guy.  Saleh or Weaver fit that mold.    

My Prediction: Vance Joseph- He deserves another shot, he got shortchanged when he was the head coach in Denver.  It’s not an easy job and it’s not that desirable but Joseph’s knowledge of the franchise should make him more amenable to taking the position. 

Quick Hitters

One of the more interesting things about this hiring cycle is that most of the good young coaches teams are looking at are defensive guys.  Jesse Minter (Chargers DC), Anthony Weaver (Miami DC), Jeff Hafley (Green Bay DC), Anthony Campanile (Jacksonville DC), Chris Shula (Rams DC), Ejiro Evero (Carolina DC), Aden Durde (Seattle DC), and Matt Burke (Houston DC) are roughly in their 40s (Shula is 39, Burke turns 50 in March).  These are guys who are seen as being ready to step into head coaching roles.  It’s been said that there aren’t a lot of good young offensive guys which is why Kevin Stefanski and Mike McDaniel are getting so many interviews, good offensive guys who are still young but are on their second job.  Klint Kubiak is the only young offensive coordinator getting serious consideration and even he has people wondering if he’s ready. 

With that said, there are a ton of really young up-and-coming offensive minds that just aren’t quite ready for the top job yet but should be getting OC jobs for some of these defensive guys.  It’s actually a really good thing for a few of the older DCs like Brian Flores, Robert Saleh, Vance Joseph, and Jim Schwartz because these guys may have failed before because they missed on the offensive coordinators they hired.  Certainly, that was true for Flores in Miami and Saleh had OC and QB problems with the Jets. 

Davis Webb (Denver QB coach), Grant Udinski (Jacksonville OC), Nate Scheelhaase (Rams passing game coordinator), Mike LaFluer (Rams OC), Klay Kubiak (San Francisco OC), Thomas Brown (New England passing game coordinator), Tommy Rees (Cleveland OC), Klayton Adams (Dallas OC) and Dan Pitcher (Cincinnati OC) might be guys to look at if your team needs a new OC and there are a few established teams looking to make changes there.  Philadelphia, Detroit, LA Chargers and Kansas City are all looking for new OCs for their well-established head coaches.  The young guys may stay with the coaches they are already working with but they should be looking to move for a play calling job if they don’t have one right now. 

The 4 Big OC Jobs

Kansas City Chiefs – Andy Reid has allowed both Eric Bienemy and Matt Nagy to call plays for him so this is an attractive job.  I don’t think he’ll put one of these young guys in charge of rebooting the Mahomes offense though.  I think he hires Kliff Kingsbury.  Mahomes knows Kingsbury well and while it won’t be the Air Raid from their college days, it will be a better passing game than Nagy had going last year.

Philadelphia Eagles – This could be the Brian Daboll spot when Las Vegas screws up the Flores/Daboll pairing.  Nick Sirianni needs another new offensive coordinator and it’s an even numbered year so it should be a good one this time.  Kevin Patullo (2025), Kellen Moore (2024), Brian Johnson (2023), Shane Steichen (2022), it’s a pattern.  Daboll is a good offensive mind and he’s better off as a play caller in the booth and not coaching on the sidelines, he’s too emotional on the sidelines.  This is a GM Howie Roseman thing, Sirianni isn’t hiring this OC.  He’s going to shoot for the moon with Daboll and McDaniel first but he may have to settle for Mike Kafka.    

Detroit Lions – In their dreams they get Mike McDaniel if he doesn’t get one of the better head coaching jobs.  If it’s between the Browns head coaching job and Detroit’s OC job, take the Detroit job Mike.  I think he gets the Atlanta job so they have to move on.  This is where one of the young guys could go shine.  One of McVay’s guys, Mike LaFluer or Nate Scheelhaase, would be excellent.  Maybe they go the Shanahan tree and grab Klay Kubiak, he’s the younger brother of Klink Kubiak and is San Fransico’s OC.  The dark horse for me here is Thomas Brown, the Patriots passing game coordinator.  No ties that I know of, but he is well respected in the league and he did a great job for the three games he was promoted to OC in Chicago last year before he then got promoted again to head coach.  I don’t want to see the Patriots lose him because if Josh McDaniels does ever get another head coaching shot, I would like Brown to take over as OC, but that’s a pipe dream, he’s getting an OC job before McDaniels could possibly leave.

Los Angeles Chargers – This one is a mystery to me because Jim Harbaugh doesn’t have an extensive network in the league at this point.  He took most of his staff from guys his brother John had in Baltimore but he just fired Greg Roman so there aren’t any others to pick from.  Mike Kafka (Giants OC/interim HC), Matt Nagy (Kansas City OC), or another retread OC feels like a Harbaugh pick. He should really look to the Rams or 49ers staffs.  One name that has a tie to the Chargers organization but not Harbaugh is Miami Dolphins OC Frank Smith.  With Mike McDaniel gone I would assume they are moving on from him but I believe he’s still under contract with Miami until they hire a new coach.  Smith is well known for his offensive line and run game prowess so that would fit quite nicely with what the Chargers need.   

College Football Coaching Carousel

The college football coaching carousel is already insane and it’s only going to get worse. There are more firings to come and there will be big time coaches moving around opening more jobs as one goes from one job to another.  I’m going to take a shot at predicting who ends up at each spot, I’m aware it’s a fool’s errand but here I am.  A few notes to keep in mind, Curt Cignetti and Matt Rhule have signed extensions with Indiana and Nebraska so they are not leaving their current roles.  I’m not including Joe Brady, the Bills offensive coordinator because I don’t think the top jobs would wait until after Buffalo’s season and he’s going to be an NFL coaching candidate. 

I’m going to start at the bigger jobs to look at how the dominos fall as one coach moving opens other jobs.  There are eight jobs in the Power 4 conferences (Big Ten, SEC, Big 12, ACC) currently open; LSU, Florida, Penn St., Arkansas, Oklahoma St., Virginia Tech, UCLA, and Stanford.  I think Auburn, Kentucky, and Florida St. are all going to also be open eventually.  In this exercise I don’t think Wisconsin or Michigan St. will fire their coaches and I’ll get to them later.  The one other Big Ten job that could come open is Maryland depending on how their season ends, and it could realistically go either way.  The breakdown for me is LSU, Florida, Penn St., Auburn, and Florida St. would be the top five. Kentucky, Arkansas, Virginia Tech, Oklahoma St., UCLA, and Stanford would be the next six. Then I’ll get to the positions that come open from coaching taking some of those jobs.  Hope you like dominos.  There’s a solid group of head coaches from the Group of 6 teams (G6) and there are a few top level coordinators in the Power 4 who will get jobs this cycle.  Let’s get started.

LSU

The is the top job on the market, sorry to Penn St. and Florida but LSU has the advantage.  Three of the last four coaches at LSU; Nick Saban, Les Miles, and Ed Orgeron, all won National Championships.  Obviously, Brian Kelly is the one who didn’t but the fact that Orgeron and Miles did should be proof that LSU has advantages.  Saban is a legend, it’s not strange he won a title there, Miles and Orgeron are not great coaches, I’m not even sure they were good coaches, but they managed to win National Championships at LSU.  Florida has won National Championships but it took legendary coaches like Steve Spurrier and Urban Meyer to win there, mere mortals have watched their careers wither in Gainesville.   

LSU has unbelievable instate talent with minimal instate competition for that talent.  At Florida you’re competing with Florida St. and Miami, plus other schools like UCF, USF, FAU, and others are poaching the depth in the state from you.  Penn St. does have some instate competition from Pitt but they also have Ohio St., Michigan, and others trying to pick off talent from Pennsylvania which is not as talent rich as Louisiana.  

Financially, LSU, Penn St., and Florida are not going to be that much different so it comes down to the situation.  The one issue that could hold back LSU is the governor of Louisiana getting involved.  I don’t think he was wrong to want to limit AD Scott Woodward after he’s given out two of the biggest buyout contracts in college football history (Kelly at LSU, and Jimbo Fisher at Texas A&M).  However, Woodward does have a solid track record overall hiring coaches. He poached Kim Mulkey for LSU’s women’s basketball program and hired Jay Johnson as the baseball coach.  They just announced Woodward is out as AD and that’s not going to be helpful.  Firing him was unnecessary, I think I would have just kept him out of the contract negotiations. By the way, he wasn’t the only person who would have had to sign off on the contract for Brian Kelly. 

The Pick: Lane Kiffin (Ole Miss)

I’m going with them winning the Lane Kiffin sweepstakes over Florida.  They will outbid Florida but also offer the highest upside for Kiffin.  There’s a feeling Kiffin wants to get back to Florida after his stint as FAU’s head coach and he does have a certain Florida vibe, maybe it’s the visor.  However, Kiffin has always looked for the next step and I think he will see the path to a National Championship is easier at LSU than Florida and that’s his choice.  This would lead to an opening at Ole Miss; I’ll address that later. 

Runner up: Eli Drinkwitz (Missouri).  If Kiffin takes Florida, LSU pivots quickly. 

Disaster candidate: Jimbo Fisher (currently collecting buyout money from Texas A&M).  If they strike out on Kiffin, Drinkwitz, and a couple of other names, would Woodward have called up his old buddy from Texas A&M?  Fisher was the offensive coordinator at LSU in 2003 when Saban led them to a National Championship.  Somehow, I don’t think the LSU fanbase would be happy with him being the pick.  With Woodward out this is much less likely but he does still have old ties to LSU.

Sneaky Good Idea: Will Stein (Oregon offensive coordinator). Something tells me he’s going to be a good head coach.

Florida

Penn St. and Florida are the next best jobs and I’m addressing the Florida job next because it’s linked to LSU and I don’t think there’s ton of overlap with Penn St.  Florida’s number one choice is Kiffin, if they lose him to LSU, it’s a more wide-open field.  Drinkwitz is a possibility but he’s not a slam dunk and I think they could lose Drinkwitz to another team while they pursue Kiffin.  Drinkwitz might prefer being a different SEC school’s number one choice instead of feeling like he’s taking Kiffin’s leftovers.  I’ll get to Drinkwitz below.  USF Alex Golesh is a name to watch here but I’m not sure he’s a big enough name for the Gators.  They just did the “hire the hot group of five” (or six now) coach with Billy Napier and it didn’t work.  They will aim higher and if they miss on Kiffin and Drinkwitz, there is one major conference coach who will crawl over broken glass for the Florida job and not care if he’s the third choice or the 15th choice. 

The Pick: Jedd Fisch (Washington)

Fisch bounced around in his coaching career as an assistant for many years before finally landing the Arizona job, then he quickly jumped to Washington two years ago.  He rebuilt Arizona quickly; he then took over a decimated roster after Kalen DeBoer left Washington for Alabama and he has them looking pretty good in year two.  He went to school at Florida and started his career as a GA there and he would be ecstatic to make Florida his destination job.  I’m not sure Fisch has ever stayed anywhere more than three years but he would certainly hope to change that with a move to Gainesville.  He’s not the sexiest hire but he might be the right one for Florida.  This would open the Washington job and there’s an excellent candidate out there for that one. 

Runner up: Well, Fisch is really third on my list for them but is it’s not him they could go with Golesh or maybe they make a run at Rhett Lashlee at SMU.  I do think the Florida fans may want to temper their expectations.

Disaster Candidate: James Franklin.  Sorry but Franklin is a great recruiter who isn’t a great coach. There is too much pressure at Florida and Franklin would crumble under it. 

Sneaky Good Idea: Clark Lea (Vanderbilt). He should be high on everyone’s list but I’m not sure Florida would hire Vanderbilt’s coach.   

Penn St.

Curt Cignetti and Matt Rhule already used this job to get extensions and raises at their current schools and other coaches may do the same.  The pressure to win at Penn St. is enormous and the fact they fired James Franklin after he basically won ten games every year is crazy.  However, they weren’t wrong to fire Franklin if they want to truly compete for National Championships, he had taken them as far as he could.  What Penn St. needs is a real coach, not just a guy who can recruit and then tries to hire coaches to coach.  They need the guy who can raise the level of play of the great players they can get.  Great players have gone to Penn St. and played well but they are usually guys who were 4- or 5-star recruits and they don’t actually get better they’re just good players to start with.  Even if you are a top recruit, it doesn’t mean coaching can’t make you better.  Guys like Nick Saban and Kirby Smart routinely get 5-star guys but they also develop them into the best player they can be, that was not Franklin. The guy they need isn’t the flashy name but he’s the right coach. 

The Pick: Matt Campbell (Iowa State)

I hate giving Iowa St. credit in any way but Matt Campbell is an excellent football coach.  He routinely takes two-star and three-star recruits and makes them way better players.  What he could do with the upper-level recruits Penn St. can get would be scary.  He’s always had good coordinators but Campbell is a legitimately good football coach himself.  He’s rebuffed many opportunities in the past but Penn St. is one of the premiere coaching jobs in the country, it’s in an elite conference, and there is no chance Iowa St. can compete financially with the Nittany Lions.  It’s time for Campbell to make the move and competing in the Big Ten is where he belongs.  It would be ripping out the hearts of Iowa St. fans again if Penn St. takes a great coach from them.  To all those Penn St. fans thinking he’s not a big enough name, just look at your wrestling program and remember where Cael Sanderson came from, you’re in good hands. 

Runner up: Jon Sumrall (Tulane) Sumrall is arguably the best G6 coach on the carousel this season, he’s been excellent at both Troy and Tulane.  He’s headed to the SEC in my opinion but Penn St. would be lucky to have him.  I would be more than happy to see him stick around Tulane until Kirk Ferentz retires, he would be at the top of my board. 

Disaster candidate: Brian Kelly (former LSU). There’s a thought that Kelly’s “failure” at LSU (he did win a lot just not enough for them) was because he wasn’t a culture fit.  His terrible Louisiana accent notwithstanding, Kelly’s personality was his downfall. Some would call him gruff, that’s the polite way to put it, he’s a jerk, always has been.  I don’t think his personality would endear him to the Penn St. faithful.  He needs a lower profile place where they can hide his personality.

Sneaky Good Idea: Bob Chesney (James Madison).  He’s a great coach from the region who took over James Madison after Curt Cignetti and has kept them winning.  He won at Holy Cross before that.  He’s not a big enough name but he might just be a really good coach and someone is going to hire him.  They may be missing out.

Auburn

Auburn has high hopes for their football program and they keep grasping at straws trying to find the solution at head coach, it has not gone well.  Hugh Freeze is in over his head and they need another new coach.  They went way outside the box when they hired Bryan Harsin from Boise St. a few years ago, that was a disaster. Then they overcorrected with thinking Freeze was the right fit.  They should try to hit one straight down the fairway, a good coach who can fit anywhere. 

The Pick: Eli Drinkwitz (Missouri)

Remember I said Drinkwitz might prefer to go somewhere that’s he’s the first choice and not the consolation prize.  I think Auburn should put on the full-court press and get him before Florida takes their eye off Kiffin and before Penn St. gets any farther down their list.  Drinkwitz won at Appalachian St and he’s winning at Missouri.  He’s been a great evaluator of talent both with players and coaches and Auburn needs someone to get everything there aligned.  Auburn has a strange history with coaches and I might actually tell Drinkwitz to look elsewhere but Auburn can be a giant and they are going to make it worth his while.  Missouri can compete with the salary but they don’t have the same advantages Auburn has in the SEC since Missouri is an SEC school that’s not actually in SEC country. 

Runner Up: Jon Sumrall (Tulane).  I’m not sure this is really a runner up because I think Sumrall would prefer a different SEC destination, but Auburn can think he would choose them. 

Disaster candidate: Ed Orgeron (unemployed interim coach specialist).  If Drinkwitz goes to Florida, and Sumrall goes to (SPOILER ALERT) Kentucky, maybe baggage at Auburn hurts them with some of the up-and-comers and they end up with Orgeron (this is never happening, Auburn donors are far too involved to let this occur).

Sneaky Good Idea: Glenn Schumann (Georgia defensive coordinator).  Not sure how sneaky it is, his name has come up for openings but he’s a coordinator so I’m not sure they would even consider it.  The last Georgia defensive coordinator to take a head job was Dan Lanning so there’s that.  Auburn could do worse, actually, they usually do.    

Florida St.

The Seminoles are basically letting Mike Norvell finish out the season but he’s a dead man walking right now and it’s understandable.  The last two seasons have been a disaster.  They are going to have to pay a major buyout for Norvell so they won’t likely be shopping for a coach in the same tax bracket as these other schools.  Florida St. doesn’t have the deep pockets of a Big Ten or SEC school but they are a major brand and they hope to be in one of those conferences one day.  They need a good coach that isn’t extra expensive and can turn this program back around. 

The Pick: Clark Lea (Vanderbilt)

This is a tough one because Lea has built Vanderbilt into a real football program and he’s an alumnus.  It’s going to take a special job to get him to move but Florida St. is a very prominent program.  Vanderbilt is in the SEC and Florida St. is not but Vanderbilt isn’t in the business of investing in football the way Florida St. is long-term.  It would suck for him to leave but this is the time to go.  Lea wasn’t exactly lighting it up at Vanderbilt until Diego Pavia transferred in and now Pavia will be done.  It’s the right time to go and he can say he’s leaving Vanderbilt in a better place than where he found it. 

Runner up: Alex Golesh (South Florida).  A very good alternative if they can’t get Lea.

Disaster candidate: Ryan Silverfield (Memphis).  This is not a slight on Silverfield, he’s proven to be a good head coach.  He’s a disaster as a Florida St. candidate only because Mike Norvell was hired from Memphis and Silverfield replaced him there.  No way Florida St. can sell the idea of hiring the next guy from Memphis.  It’s a dumb reason but it does matter to them.  

Sneaky Good Idea: Jeff Brohm (Louisville).  I’ve heard Brohm’s name come up and getting him to leave his alma mater Louisville will be even harder than getting Lea to do so.  However, Brohm is an excellent coach and if Florida St. pulled this off, hats off, that would be incredible. 

Virginia Tech

Virgina Tech needs a reset after striking out with Brent Pry.  They may make a play for Shane Beamer at South Carolina but following in the legendary footsteps of his father seems like a bad idea.  Beamer may want to find a soft-landing spot after his tough year at South Carolina but he would be better off not going back to Va Tech. 

The Pick: James Franklin (former Penn St.)

This one feels like it has been in motion since the minute he was fired.  Franklin is still a young coach and has the energy it will take to fix Virginia Tech and he’s got something to prove.  It would be a solid hire for the school, don’t overthink it. 

Runner up: Billy Napier (former Florida).  I haven’t heard his name for any openings but he’s a good coach and they could do worse. 

Disaster candidate: Brian Kelly (former LSU). He qualifies as a disaster at anywhere that has actual expectations and where he has to talk to people.

Sneaky Good Idea: Bob Chesney (James Madison). Again, a job in this region would be a good fit and he’s a good coach.

Kentucky

This job isn’t open yet but it looks like Mark Stoops could be gone any day now.  It’s a massive buyout but this program is slipping and they can’t afford to let it slip any farther.  Also, they have the opportunity to bring home a homegrown future coaching star and if they don’t act now, he’s getting a different job. 

The Pick: Jon Sumrall (Tulane). 

Sumrall is at the top of any list of coaches coming from the G6 teams.  He was a LB at Kentucky and was an assistant there before he became the head coach at Troy.  He parlayed Troy into Tulane and he’s been excellent there.  If the Wildcats don’t hire him now, someone else in the SEC or Big Ten will and then it will be very hard to get him.  He might be Auburn’s top choice, if Kiffin leaves Ole Miss, Sumrall’s on that list too.

Runner up: Ryan Silverfield (Memphis) or Alex Golesh (South Florida).  I’m not sure Kentucky will be able to spend on a sitting head coach from a Power 4 school so if Sumrall turns them down, they look to the other top G6 guys. 

Disaster candidate: Anyone not name Jon Sumrall.  If they pay Mark Stoops’ ridiculous buyout, they better be sure Sumrall is taking the job.  The owe Stoops something like $38 million and it’s all due within 30 days of his firing, that’s insane.  Kudos to Stoops’ agent.  Sumrall would be a homerun hire for them, anyone else is a disappointment. 

Sneaky Good Idea: Don’t put a one lump sum payment buyout on a coach’s contract like this ever again. Especially for a guy who showed you his ceiling was winning nine games every few years.  Stoops deserves credit for rebuilding Kentucky football but he was well compensated the entire time and now his reward for tanking the program is winning the lottery.  That’s bad business.

Arkansas

It was time to move on from Sam Pittman and Bobby Petrino is not the answer.  Don’t be stupid and go looking for someone outside your comfort zone like you did when you hired Bret Bielema.  Stick to someone you know. 

The Pick: Rhett Lashlee (SMU)

Lashlee is an Arkansas native who built a good SMU team and took them to the college football playoff last year.  He’s an excellent coach and there’s no better fit.  I say it all the time, don’t over think it.  SMU has deep pockets to compete with any offer but let’s not pretend Arkansas can’t beat it. 

Runner up: Eric Morris (North Texas). He’s a Texas guy who could recruit to Arkansas pretty well and he’s a QB savant. 

Disaster hire: Billy Napier (former Florida).  I don’t think Arkansas fans would take too well to Florida’s reject. 

Sneaky Good Idea: Collin Klein (Texas A&M offensive coordinator).  Klein is a young coach who has been an offensive coordinator at Kansas St. and Texas A&M and they would be getting a guy on his way up.  It might be a big jump but he might be worth the risk. 

Oklahoma St.

Mike Gundy was there for a very long time as both a coach and a player.  He defined Oklahoma St. football for a generation, now they need to move on.  A new, young offensive minded coach would look good in Stillwater. 

The Pick: Eric Morris (North Texas)

Morris is only 40 and he hasn’t been coaching that long in college but he’s been a head coach at Incarnate Word and at North Texas, he was also an offensive coordinator at Washington St. when they were still in a major conference.  Oklahoma St. isn’t the most attractive job out there but it has its advantages.  If you get a guy like Morris who can recruit in Texas and find you a QB, that’s a great place to start.

Runner up: Collin Klein (Texas A&M OC).  Same reasons as the Arkansas job although it’s not as big of a leap. 

Disaster candidate: Ben Arbuckle (Oklahoma OC). Arbuckle is 29 and not ready.  He’s had success with John Mateer at Washington St. and some at Oklahoma but he shouldn’t be getting this big of a job. 

Sneaky Good Idea: Just hire Morris, this isn’t hard.   

UCLA

The Bruins are flailing along and trying to find a direction.  Tim Skipper is the interim after they fired Deshuan Foster but they need to look for someone with some real head coaching experience to lead the program.  That’s not going to be easy with an athletic department that isn’t likely to commit a ton of resources.  They could go with a current coordinator but I think they should look for the guy looking for a soft landing somewhere new. 

The Pick: Dave Aranda (Baylor)

Aranda has had Baylor up and down over the years and generally just as soon as it looks like they may fire him, he has a solid year.  Maybe it’s time to get off that particular rollercoaster.  Aranda was born and raised in California and UCLA may just be desperate enough to want a guy needing a lifeline.  Aranda cut his teeth as a defensive coordinator so there’s even the possibility he might be willing to keep Jerry Neuheisel as his offensive coordinator.  Aranda is a good coach needing a reset and UCLA needs a coach who’s willing to accept a job that may not be perfect. 

Runner up: D’Anton Lynn (USC defensive coordinator).  Lynn was formerly the defensive coordinator at UCLA and may have been the guy who replaced Chip Kelly if he hadn’t just left for the USC DC job.  He would also potentially keep Neuheisel so he’s not the worst choice. 

Disaster hire: PJ Fleck (Minnesota).  His name routinely gets floated for this job but I don’t think the UCLA administration would find it fun to have Fleck around complaining about not getting enough support from the school.  He’s not exactly the type of guy to suffer in silence. 

Sneaky Good Idea: Tosh Lupoi (Oregon defensive coordinator).  Great recruiter and a guy looking for a chance to be a head coach.  He too could keep Neuheisel.  It’s not a dealbreaker that a new coach has to keep him but Neuheisel seems to be beloved in that locker room and loves UCLA.  He’s done a good job taking over and making the offense fun again since the purge of Deshaun Foster and other coaches.  Don’t kill the vibe. 

Stanford

Frank Reich is the interim coach that Andrew Luck hired to hold down the fort after they let Troy Taylor go over the summer for non-football related reasons.  I don’t have a good feel for this job because the only name mentioned I’ve seen is Tavita Pritchard who is the Ravens QB coach.  He’s a former Stanford QB and coached there too.  He’s really young and doesn’t have a ton of experience.  Luck is in charge of hiring the next coach and he would be wise to look at UCLA’s hiring of Deshaun Foster and steer clear of hiring a guy just because of his ties to the school.  There are a couple of good coaches not linked to Stanford that Luck should look into. 

The Pick: Sean Lewis (San Diego St.)

Lewis is an offensive mastermind and was an excellent coach at Kent St. and if you know anything about Kent St. football you know how impressive that was.  He made the mistake of leaving there to be Deion Sanders’ OC at Colorado.  That didn’t go well but he was smart enough to get out before it hurt his stock.  He got the San Diego St. job and has done well.  He runs a unique offense and Stanford probably needs to do something a little different to compete.  It a tough situation with their academic standards and the weird placement in the ACC but Stanford can be a good team. 

Runner up: Ken Niumatalolo (San Jose St.). Niumatalolo was once the head coach at Navy and ran the triple option there but now at San Jose St. he runs a wide-open spread offense.  Talk about a guy who could give Stanford something unique.  He’s an excellent coach but he is 60 years old and may not want the headache of a rebuild at a tough place like Stanford.

Disaster hire: Tavita Pritchard (Baltimore Ravens QB coach).  I’m not knocking Pritchard as a coach, by all accounts he’s doing a good job.  However, he’s 36, never been a head coach, and this is a heavy lift.  The Deshaun Foster/UCLA thing would scare me away from this.  Maybe if you hire Lewis, he succeeds and moves on in a few years and then Pritchard comes back after being at least a coordinator in the NFL or college.  Give it a little time.

Sneaky Good Idea: Jonathan Smith (Michigan St.) Smith was a rising star at Oregon St. and now in his second year at Michigan St. he might get fired.  He’s a west coast guy and maybe getting back that way would be good for him.  I don’t think it’s a good idea for Michigan St. to give up on him this early but he may be like Dave Aranda and looking for a soft-landing spot. 

Maryland

This is another job that isn’t open and depending on how they finish, it may not.  Mike Locksley has been a big-time recruiter in his career as an assistant but as a head coach, he’s been hit and miss.  His coaching hasn’t been great at Maryland.  There are a lot of great players in the area and he hasn’t taken advantage.  He has a very good freshman QB this year but they may only go 5-7, 6-6, or 7-5 at best.  He’s had plenty of time and Maryland has a chance to get a good up-and-coming coach. 

The pick: Charles Huff (Southern Miss)

Huff is a Maryland native and he’s coached at places like Alabama, Penn St. and even the NFL.  He was the head coach at Marshall and took over at Southern Miss this season.  He’s won at both places and he would be a great get for Maryland.

Runner up: I don’t think there’s a great second choice.  Huff should be the guy if they move on.

Disaster hire: Brian Kelly (former LSU).  I’m just taking another shot at Kelly. 

Sneaky Good Idea: Bob Chesney (James Madison). Seriously, do I have to say it again? He’s a good coach.

The Domino Jobs (their coach left for a better opportunity)

Ole Miss

Lost: Lane Kiffin

Hire: Pete Golding (Ole Miss defensive coordinator). 

Golding has been a good coach at Ole Miss and was a good DC at Alabama before that.  He would likely have to wrestle with Kiffin to keep some of the staff but he’s their best shot at keeping the Kiffin thing going. 

Other options: Alex Golesh (South Florida), Jon Sumrall (Tulane)

Missouri

Lost: Eli Drinkwitz

Hire: Ryan Silverfield (Memphis).

Silverfield might be the runner up for a number of jobs because he’s good but maybe not ready for the upper level of the Big Ten or SEC.  Missouri is a good next step for him.  Better program, better conference, and working towards the bigger jobs.

Other options: Alex Golesh (South Florida), Colin Klein (Texas A&M OC)

Iowa St.

Lost: Matt Campbell

Hire: Jason Eck (New Mexico).

He has done a great job everywhere he’s been and he does have ties to AD Jamie Pollard.  Eck was an offensive lineman and started his coaching career at Wisconsin when Pollard was there.

Other options: Nathan Scheelhaase (LA Rams Assistant Coach), Tim Polasek (North Dakota St.)

SMU

Lost: Rhett Lashlee

Hire: Will Stein (Oregon offensive coordinator). 

Stein spent a lot of time coaching in the state of Texas and he would be a great candidate to step in and keep the offense humming at SMU.  He’s a future coaching star. 

Other options: Collin Klein (Texas A&M OC), Jason Eck (New Mexico)

Washington

Lost: Jedd Fisch

Hire: Ryan Grubb (Alabama OC). 

Grubb was Kalen DeBoer’s right hand man during Washington’s run to the National Championship Game a couple of years ago.  He’s a great offensive mind for college (his year with the Seahawks went poorly, not all his fault).  And he clearly liked the area so maybe he will stay longer than DeBoer or Fisch did.

Other options: Will Stein (Oregon OC), Tosh Lupoi (Oregon DC)

Tulane

Lost: Jon Sumrall

Hire: Collin Klein (Texas A&M OC)

Klein is a young coach at 36 and while there’s a very good chance, he may end up the head coach at Kansas St. someday, Chris Klieman is only 58 and Klein should get some experience as a head coach.  If Sumrall moves up to a bigger job, that’s the last two Tulane head coaches who moved up (Willie Fritz became the Houston head coach).  This is a good job to have.

Other options: Charles Huff (Southern Miss), Billy Napier (former Florida)

Memphis

Lost: Ryan Silverfield

Hire: Tim Cramsey (Memphis OC)

The last time Memphis lost their head coach they replaced Mike Norvell with Silverfield.  Here they do it again by promoting Cramsey who is their offensive coordinator.  It’s not the sexiest hire but he’s a solid coach. 

Other options: Brian Brohm (Memphis OC), Andy Kotelnicki (Penn St. OC), Brian Hartline (Ohio St. OC) 

Vanderbilt

Lost: Clark Lea

Hire: Bob Chesney (James Madison)

I mentioned Chesney for a couple of jobs but I haven’t given him one yet.  He would be an excellent choice for Vanderbilt.  He isn’t working with the biggest budget at JMU and Vanderbilt would be similar.  Chesney can do less with more.  He should be getting one of these jobs.

Other options: Andy Kotelnicki (Penn St. OC), Mike Denbrock (Notre Dame OC)

Baylor

Lost: Dave Aranda

Hire: Alex Golesh (South Florida)

Golesh should also be getting a promotion and heading to Baylor and bringing his offensive acumen to a place like Baylor seems fitting. 

Other options: Eric Morris (North Texas), Will Stein (Oregon OC)

The 3 Other Jobs (Someone will take them)

Oregon St

They fired Trent Bray after less than a season and a half after promoting him when Jonathan Smith left for Michigan St.  He was a young defensive coordinator and they didn’t give him much time.  Oregon St. is still in the PAC-2 until they get the PAC-whatever back up and running.  It’s not a great job but someone will take it. 

The Pick: Paul Chryst

Chryst wasn’t lighting up the world at Wisconsin but he didn’t deserve to get fired either and they are paying for that mistake now.  He wants to get back into coaching but he isn’t going to be a hot commodity.  He would be an excellent pick to resurrect Oregon St. and get them on track as the new conference gets going. 

UAB

They fired Trent Dilfer and for good reason.  He was a disaster and anyone is an upgrade.  This program deserves a good coach.

The Pick: Billy Napier (former Florida). 

Napier is a good coach.  He was in over his head at Florida but he was an excellent coach at Louisiana.  UAB would be a good landing spot for him. 

Colorado St.

Jay Norvell did okay at CSU but never quite as well as he did at Nevada.  CSU is at best a stepping stone for a good young coach and at worst it’s a last stop for a guy on his way out.  Maybe this is the Brian Kelly stop.  I highly doubt he would swallow his pride enough to take this job but it would be a good place for him, no one is paying attention to Colorado St. 

The Pick: I don’t have a good choice for this one.  I say go for the up-and-coming coach like a Brian Brohm (Louisville OC), Andy Kotelnicki (Penn St. OC), or Tim Polasek (North Dakota St) but I’m not sure they would take it.  It’s possible this is a Mike Gundy spot.   

The two Big Ten jobs that could open but won’t.

Wisconsin

Luke Fickell needs a miracle because even if he survives this year, Wisconsin’s outlook next year can’t be great.  He’s a dead man walking but Wisconsin’s AD doesn’t want to admit his mistake and they really don’t want to pay his buyout.  They are talking about investing more money in the roster and while that would help, Fickell’s inability to keep a QB healthy has killed his team every year.  Wisconsin hasn’t had the offensive line they are used to or the defense they used to have so it’s an uphill climb.  It is possible things change and the Wisconsin AD gets the boot too and both are gone.  If they need a coach, Jason Eck (New Mexico) is a former Badger and if the AD is gone, they could try to mend fences with Jim Leonhard (Denver Broncos assistant).  Neither would necessarily break the bank so they could get it done. 

Michigan St. 

I thought the Jonathan Smith hire was a good one at the time and I would give him more time to right the ship.  With the portal, it’s possible to turn a roster around quickly if you make the right moves.  Maybe Smith is a bad fit but I think Michigan St. should sit out this coaching cycle, give Smith the resources to figure it out, and if he fails next season, maybe the coaching carousel isn’t so tough. They have turned that job into a revolving door since Mark Dantonio retired and it’s not a good idea to continually turn over the job.  They didn’t have a choice with Mel Tucker; he had to go. They have a choice with Smith and they should hold on to him. 

Well, if you made it this far, kudos to you and thanks for sticking around.  I probably got it all wrong and if Lane Kiffin picks Florida or stays at Ole Miss, the dominos may fall in a completely different way.  That’s the fun of dominos.